Science Behind Teaching Reading Comprehension

slide_41

Teaching Reading for Comprehension

  • Reading comprehension depends heavily on spoken language comprehension.  As children master the skill of word comprehension, their reading comprehension improves dramatically (p. 95).
  • To develop reading comprehension, children need to develop their vocabulary and linguistic knowledge and thoughtfully interact with the text to derive meaning (p. 95).
  • Oral vocabulary becomes the basis for comprehension in reading (p. 96).
  • The larger the child’s oral vocabulary, the easier it is to understand the text.  If the word is not in the child’s lexicon, he will need to determine meaning through other ways (p. 96).
  • Some vocabulary must be taught directly, but most vocabulary is taught indirectly (p. 96).
  • Children learn new words indirectly through oral and written language.  They learn directly when they are explicitly taught individual words and word learning strategies (p. 96).
  • Direct instruction is effective for teaching words representing complex concepts that are not part of everyday experiences (p. 97).
  • Repeated exposure to new words aids word learning and linguistic knowledge.  Children need to see, hear, and read specific words to learn them and understand their various meanings (p. 97).
  • Factors such as ability, age, and text density have an impact on the chances that students will learn new words in context (p. 97).
  • Low-ability students only have an 8% chance of learning new words in context, 19% for high-ability students.  4th graders have an 8% chance while 11th graders have a 33% chance (p. 97).
  • When text density is low (1 new word/150), the greater the chance of learning a new word (30%).  The chances drop to 7% when there is 1 new word per 10 (p. 97).
  • Linguistic knowledge:  hear, distinguish, categorize speech sounds (phonology), understand the rules that constrain how words are put together in phrases and sentences (syntax), understand the meaning of individual words and sentences and the relationships between them (semantics) (p. 97).
  • Please see pages 98-100 in David Sousa’s How the Brain Learns to Read for a “How to Teach Vocabulary” chart.
  • Children who are first learning to read are using substantial mental effort sounding out words so fewer cerebral resources remain for text comprehension (p. 100).
  • It is critical to develop fluency in word recognition.  When fluent, word recognition requires far less mental effort, freeing up the child’s cognitive capacity for understanding what is read (p. 100).
  • Explicit instruction in word recognition to the point of fluency is vital for text comprehension (p. 100).
  • A study by Tan and Nicholson (1997) showed struggling primary readers who were taught new words with instruction that emphasized recognition to the point of fluency ~ reading words in isolation ~ answered more comprehension questions than those whose emphasis was on meanings (p. 101).
  • Discussions prior to reading improves comprehension, and activating prior knowledge improves fluency (p. 101).
  • Possessing prior knowledge could stimulate neural networks and visual processing sites  making word recognition less challenging (p. 101).
  • Good readers read for a purpose and are active using their own personal experience and knowledge (p. 101).
  • Text comprehension is improved with direct, explicit instruction including self-monitoring, graphic and semantic organizers, answering questions, generating questions, recognizing story structure, and summarizing (p. 101).
  • Teaching strategies in context of specific academic areas is best.  Cooperative learning is useful for helping students understand content area texts (p. 102).
  • Please see pages 102-107 in David Sousa’s How the Brain Learns to Read for a “How to Teach Comprehension” chart.
  • Teach students to become critical readers by fostering inquiry ~ encouraging students to question, make predictions and support value judgments.  This employs higher order thinking skills (p. 107).
  • Critical reading strategies include:  previewing, contextualizing (recognizing their own values, time, place vs. those in text), questioning (this helps in retaining new learning), challenging beliefs, evaluating an argument, outlining/summarizing, comparing/contrasting the arguments of various authors (p. 108).
  • To sharpen critical reading skills, ask questions about the reader, writer, the writer’s arguments, evidence, conclusions, the writer’s use of evidence to support the conclusion, and the reader’s reaction to the reading (p. 109).
  • Critical reading in secondary schools helps students handle difficult material well and with confidence (p. 109).
  • Research suggests initial reading instruction in a child’s home language contributes positively to a child’s ability to retain literacy in both languages and also to the prevention of reading difficulties (p. 110).
  • Literacy and other skills and knowledge transfer across languages (p. 110).
  • Reading in any language requires a solid mental lexicon of spoken vocabulary (p. 110).
  • Learning to read for meaning depends on comprehending the language of the text being read (p. 110).
  • Cooperative learning is appropriate for bilingual education (p. 111).
  • BCIRC or Bilingual Cooperative Integrated Reading Cooperative assigns students to 4 member heterogenous teams to work together after a lesson.  Students first work in their native language, then make the transition to English. This model has been particularly effective.  The teachers do the following 15 strategies before, during, and after reading during a 5 day cycle.  Build background/vocabulary, make predictions, read, partner/silent read, treasure hunt, map the story, retell, story-related writing, say words aloud/spell, check the partner, make meaningful sentences, take tests, direct instruction in reading comprehension, writing workshops, independent reading (p. 112-114).

Check out these sites related to Comprehension:

http://www.readingrockets.org/atoz/1157/video

http://www.readingrockets.org/atoz/1119/video

http://www.abcfastphonics.com/

http://www.phonicsontheweb.com/blends.php

http://www.phonictalk.com/phonics_steps.php

All page numbers above corresponds to:  How The Brain Learns To Read by David Sousa, 2014.

200w

I am happy to share my pages, but please cite me as you would expect your students to cite their sources.  Copyscape alerts me to duplicate content.copyscape-banner-white-160x56

Comments are closed.