Nonfiction Text Structures/Nonfiction Teaching/Mentor Texts

The above is a GREAT poster set sold by Really Good Stuff!  Here is the link:

Nonfiction Text Features

Strategies and Mentor Texts

I found these pdfs on the Birmingham City Schools, Alabama website:

Strategies Across the Content

Graphic Organizers to Support Reading Strategy Instruction

Teaching NONFICTION Text Structures

According to the University of New England in Maine: 

The emphasis on informational text has increased dramatically with the Common Core State Standards. According to these standards, the recommended balance of literary and informational text is as follows:

50% literary and 50% informational at 4th grade

45% literary and 55% informational at 8th grade

30% literary and 70% informational at 12th grade


There is little doubt that the Common Core State Standards have raised the primacy of informational texts while also redefining content area literacy.

This page will suggest ways to teach nonfiction reading comprehension and expository writing through teaching nonfiction text structures.  Please refer to the Reasons for the Strategies page to learn more about teaching nonfiction text features.

These are not my images.  I have received many emails requesting copies.  These are all made by Scholastic and were posted on Google Images.  What people are doing is copying them in color, and enlarging them at a copy center.  Scholastic sold these as posters, but discontinued them.  They posted the images for free use on Google Images.

 

Why is content reading and writing so difficult?  It is difficult because it requires:  knowledge of specialized vocabulary, background knowledge, good study/memory ability, nonfiction reading strategies regarding various text structures (as described here), there are multiple readability levels in a single text, the need and ability to monitor for meaning, judging importance while remembering many concepts, knowledge of source reliability, and keeping ones’ interest no matter what! 

RESEARCH SHOWS. . .Almost all of the expository texts that students read can be separated into two groups: texts that describe and texts that are affected by time (Calfee & Patrick, 1995). Elementary students encounter three descriptive and three sequential structures. 

Descriptive structures focus on the attributes of something, that is, the qualities that distinguish it from other things. For example, the writer may present the attributes of New York, glass, or rattlesnakes. The three descriptive patterns that readers encounter most frequently are list, web, and matrix (see Dymock and Nicholson [2007] for an in-depth discussion on these structures).

  • List. The simplest descriptive pattern is a list. This may be a grocery list, a list of countries that grow wheat, a list of goods and services sold by street merchants in India, or in science, the attributes of a kangaroo. 
  • Web. A web is a more complex structure than a list. This text structure is called a web because it looks like a spiderweb (Calfee & Patrick, 1995). A spiderweb has a center and a number of fine threads that form a network of lines. In a web, the attributes of an object are discussed. The attributes have a common link.  The important thing for the student to remember is that, like a list, a web describes one thing or idea, but the difference is that a web has categories.
  • Matrix. A matrix is more complex than either a list or a web. The difference between a matrix and a web or list is that a web or list describes just one thing, and a matrix describes more than one thing. It compares and contrasts two or more topics. For example, it could compare types of bears, volcanoes, bicycles, or crocodiles

Sequential structures present a series of events or steps that progress over time. Normally, sequence texts are set in a first-to-last pattern, that is, step by step.

  • String. A string is where a step-by-step description of events is given (e.g., sequence for baking cookies).
  • Cause–Effect. In the cause–effect text structure, two (or more) ideas or events interact with one another. One is the cause, and the other is an effect or result. For example, a text may cover the causes and effects of environmental disasters, such as an oil spill in the ocean. This pattern is common in history, science, and health publications.
  • Problem–Solution. In the problem–solution text structure, the writer states a problem or poses a question followed by a solution or answer in the text. There is a sequence in this kind of text: first the problems and then the solutions. 

Above in purple came from. . .

Dymock, Susan, and Tom Nicholson. ““High 5!” Strategies to Enhance Comprehension of Expository Text.” The Reading Teacher 64.3 (2010): 166-78. Web.

NONFICTION TEXT STRUCTURES ~ In the Order to be Taught:

Description, Sequence, Problem-Solution, Cause-Effect, and Compare-Contrast

1.  Writers use text structures to organize information.  Teachers should point this out whenever students read and write.

2.  Skim and scan to predict text structure(s).  Make predicting possible text structures a part of every pre-reading activity.   During reading, revise predictions about structure.

3.  Teach the signal words for each text structure.  

Description

Description:  Describes something by listing its features, characteristics, or examples.    Signal Words:

to begin with to illustrate for instance such as an example in addition
is like including also (actual sizes, shapes, colors) another characteristics are

Here are Mentor Texts to teach Description!

Balestrino, P. The Skeleton Inside You New York:  Crowell, 1971 Level N
Branley, F.M. What the Moon is Like New York:  Haper & Row, 1986 Level N
Hansen, R. & Bell, R.A. My First Book of Space New York:  Simon & Schuster, 1985 Level Q
Parish, P. Dinosaur Time New York:  Harper  & Row, 1974 Level K
Pringle, L. A Dragon in the Sky:  The Story of the Green Darner Dragonfly Scholastic/Orchard, 2001 Level W
Simon, S. Crocodiles and Alligators HarperCollins, 2001 Level P

Sequential

Sequence:   Describes events in order or tells the steps to follow in order to make or do something.  Signal Words: 

first second third later next before
then finally after when last since
now (actual use of dates) in the first place soon following previously
  • to begin with
  • most important
  • also
  • for instance
  • in fact
  • for example
  • another
  • not long after

Here are Mentor Texts to teach Sequence!

Aliki Milk from Cow to Carton New York:  Harper Collins, 1992 Level N
Cole, J. My Puppy is Born New York:  Morrow, 1981 Level  J
Giblin, J. C. The Amazing Life of Benjamin Franklin Scholastic, 2000 Level T
Lasky, K. Sugaring Time Macmillan, 1983 Level S
Macaulay, D. Castle Boston:  Houghton Mifflin, 1977 Level X
Provensen, A. The Buck Stops Here New York:  Harper Collins, 1990 Level T

Problem and Solution

Problem-Solution:  Tells about or says why there is a problem then gives one or more possible solutions to fix the problem.     Signal Words:

the question is the answer is problem is dilemma is if/then
because so/that to solve this one reason is the puzzle is
  • solution is
  • difficulty is

Here are Mentor Texts to teach Problem/Solution! 

Jackson, D. The Wildlife Detectives:  How Forensic Scientists Fight Crimes Houghton, 2000 Level Y
Levine, E. If You Traveled on the Underground Railroad New York:  Scholastic, 1988 Level Q
Montgomery, S. The Man-Eating Tigers of Sundarbans Houghton, 2001 Level R
Zoefeld, K.W. Dinosaur Young:  Uncovering the Mystery of Dinosaur Families Clarion Level S

 

Cause and Effect

Cause-Effect:  Cause is why something happened.  Effect is what happenedSignal Words:

so so that because since if…then therefore
due to hence for nevertheless consequently this led to
reason why as a result of may be due to effect of for this reason thus
  •  accordingly

Here are some Mentor Texts to teach Cause/Effect!

Aardema, Verna Why Mosquitoes Buzz in People’s Ears Dial Level N
Asch, Frank Turtle Tale Dial Level J
Blos, Joan Old Henry Level N
Branley, F.M. Flash, Crash, Rumble, Roll New York:  Harper & Row. 1985 Level N
Branley, F.M. Volcanoes New York:  Harper & Row. 1985 Level L
Branley, F.M. What Makes Day and Night? New York:  Harper & Row. 1985 Level N
Brown, Margaret The Runaway Bunny Harper Level I
Brown, Marc Arthur’s Eyes Level K
Brown, Marcia Once a Mouse Level K
Burningham, John Mr. Gumpy’s Outing Holt Level L
Carle, Eric The Grouchy Ladybug Crowell Level  J
Christelow, Eileen Five Little Monkeys Jumping on the Bed Clarion Level E
Gackenbach, Dick Harry and the Terrible Whatzit Level  J
Ginsburg, Mirra Across the Stream Greenwillow Level F
Grossman, Bill Donna O’Neeshuck Was Chased By Some Cows Harper Level L
Heller, R. The Reason for a Flower New York:  Grosset & Dunlap, 1983 Level P
Henkes, Kevin Lilly’s Purple Plastic Purse Level M
Hutchins, Pat Goodnight Owl Macmillan Level I
Hutching, Pat Rosie’s Walk Macmillan Level F
Kellogg, Steven Pinkerton Behave Level K
Noble, Trinka H. The Day Jimmy’s Boa Ate the Wash Dial Level K
Numeroff, Laura If You Give a Moose a Muffin Harper Level K
Numeroff, Laura If You Give a Mouse a Cookie Harper Level K
Polacco, Patricia The Bee Tree Putnam Level M
Rice, Eve Benny Bakes a Cake Greenwillow Level I
Rice, Eve Sam Who Never Forgets Mulberry Level K
Root, Phyllis The Old Red Rocking Chair Arcade Level M
Showers, P. What Happens to a Hamburger? New York:  Harper & Row, 1985 Level M
Turner, Ann Nettie’s Trip South   Level O
Van Lann,Nancy The Big Fat Worm Knopf Level G
Waber, Bernard Ira Sleeps Over Level L
Well, Rosemary Noisy Nora Dial Level I
Wood, Audrey and Don The Napping House Harcourt Level I
Ziefert, Harriet A New Coat for Anna Knopf Level O

Compare and Contrast

Compare – Contrast:  Shows how two or more things are alike or how they are different.   Signal Words:

as well as also too like/unlike much as similarly where as in comparison
likewise just as/ just like both in the same way either/or same as alike different
though yet less than/more than although while on the other hand but however
  • not only…but also
  • unless
  • vs.

Here are some Mentor Texts to teach Compare/Contrast!

Gibbons, G. Fire!  Fire!  New York:  Harper and Row, 1984 Level M
Murphy, J. The Great Fire Scholastic, 1995 Level R
Spier, P. We The People New York:  Doubleday, 1987 Level M

4.  Teach and model the use of graphic organizers to go with each text structure. Teachers have to identify text structures in advance and provide appropriate graphic organizer. 

5.  Teachers should spend time modeling how to determine what the text structure is, as well as note taking on a corresponding graphic organizer.   Then students should practice with teacher support. Finally, students should apply the skills and strategies they have learned for independent practice..    

6. Explicit instruction must be provided to show students how and when to use strategies such as attending to signal words while reading different content areas or using signal words when writing expository text.

7.  Use the think-aloud strategy.  The teacher reads aloud a paragraph, pausing at appropriate points to share his/her own comprehension strategies and understanding of the text.  Next, move to a shared-reading strategy, encouraging students to talk aloud as they engage in the process with the teacher. For example, the teacher asks students to talk about the clues they use to try to identify the text structure.

8.  Ask focusing questions targeting the text structure such as which signal words are used to show a particular relationship among ideas in a text structure.

9.  Pictures can be drawn to model the sequence structure.

10.  Create and provide guides and teacher-made organizers that reflect that structure of the original text. This can help students focus on the key elements of the reading selection.

11.  Present students with a completed graphic organizer as a pre-reading strategy.  Have students write a probable paragraph using a predicted text structure prior to reading.  After reading, compare students’ probable passages and the original text.

12.  Write using the text structures.  The teacher should model writing a paragraph using a particular text structure and describe his/her actions as he/she is writing. Then students write their own paragraphs using text structure/ paragraph frames as templates.

13.  Make the connection between reading and writing.  When students read an example of a particular text structure, have them write using that same text structure.  Writing can be done as a pre-reading or post-reading strategy.  

14.  Rewrite a paragraph or passage using a different text structure than the original.  Compare the two and analyze why the author might have chosen the original pattern.  

15.   Use summary frame questions to guide students’ comprehension before, during, and after reading.  Each organizational structure suggests questions which readers should consider as they are reading and be able to answer once they’ve finished reading the passage.

16.  Use text coding strategies – highlighters, Post-It Notes, etc. – targeting text structures.  Teachers must model these strategies and be consistent in the procedures (same color each time, etc.).

Identifying patterns of organization is not the final goal ~  the final goal is for students to internalize the various text structures to improve nonfiction reading comprehension and expository writing organization. 

When teaching nonfiction, think of before reading (assessing and building content knowledge), during reading (supporting and monitoring comprehension) and after reading (evaluating, extending, and transferring content knowledge) activities.  Here are some of my favorites:

BEFORE READING

Teach the Text Structure – Read above. 

K-W-L Chart – K (what I know), W (what I want to know), L (summarize what I learned).  This activity helps activate background knowledge, while building background knowledge for peers.  From their background knowledge, students can come up with a list of questions of what they would like to learn.  Synthesizing takes place when they write what they have learned.

Skimming and Scanning – This is a necessary skill to quickly find the most important information in a text.  Have students work in pairs to skim and scan the nonfiction text features  (title, headings, glossary, maps, charts, bold faced words, etc.), and have the students read only the first and last paragraphs.  Ask what they think the text or chapter will be about.  Have students write down questions/comments in one column, and facts they have quickly just learned in another column.  What will be the important points in the text or chapter?  (Teachers may ask in what section certain information would be found.  This will help assess critical thinking.) 

Anticipation Guide –  Anticipation Guides are helpful to activate background knowledge and build interest in an upcoming lesson.  Teachers determine key ideas in a text or chapter.  They write 3-8 statements which tap into the students’ background knowledge; include statements which could be opinions ~ not just facts that only can be answered by reading the text.  Have students read the statements, circling agree or disagree or yes/no.  By working with a partner, students can have discussions to expand their knowledge.  Then, students revisit the statements after reading the text, circling agree or disagree (yes/no) again.

Predict -O-Gram – This is a good way to highlight language in a text, make predictions, and create questions prior to reading.  The teacher reads aloud a portion of a text, then supplies the students with words that appear on the upcoming pages.  The students use the words to anticipate upcoming events, suggest ways the words might be used, and ask questions they believe might be answered. 

Admit Slip –   Admit slips develop a purpose for reading, which, research shows, leads to a deeper understanding of a text and higher retention of information because readers are creating connections, storing new information in meaningful ways.  Basically, the teacher copies an illustration from a textbook and/or makes a list of headings and subtitles used in the text.  The students must write 3 questions they believe the reading will answer, or list 3 pieces of information they think they will learn.  Have students discuss their predictions/questions prior to reading, and list them together.  Read to confirm/answer the items on the list.   

Teach New Words Prior to Reading – Whether you teach new words in context, through association, integration with background knowledge, structural analysis, compare/contrast, or through visuals, having a grasp on the new vocabulary will greatly improve students’ comprehension.  Connect the new words to the reading.  Not all new words need to be formally taught for the students to understand the passages, for example, many new words students may figure out in context.  Always use integration, repetition, and meaningful use to make the new vocabulary memorable.    

Advance Organizer – A graphic organizer provides students with general information about a topic before they read.  

Assessing Preconceptions and Addressing Misconceptions – Brainstorm with students what they THINK they know before a topic is introduced.  Clarify misconceptions with hands-on activities, explanations, photographs, examples. . . before the students read.  This way, they can better accept the new ideas as they read.

DURING READING

Close Reading ~ A great description of this process found on the following scholastic site http://www.scholastic.com/teachers/top-teaching/2013/04/investigating-nonfiction-part-2-digging-deeper-close-reading states that close reading is like this:

“The first time you dig your shovel in (read), you just scrape the surface off the ground. The second time you dig in (read the text again), you get a little more dirt (meaning). And every time you dig in (read) after that, your hole gets bigger and bigger until it’s just right and you get the full meaning” (quote from the UNE course).  See the chart at the bottom of my assessment research page. 

SQ4R ~ Survey, write Questions for each heading and subheading, Read the information in 1 section, Record notes as you read, Recite the important information, Review your questions.  Learn about it here:  Prezi

Reciprocal Teaching – This strategy helps students to focus and monitor their reading in order to achieve higher comprehension.  After watching teacher demonstrations of predicting, questioning, clarifying, and summarizing from a short passage, students practice these 4 with a partner.  First assign each student a reading partner.  They will read a short section together, and work together through each of the 4 stages.  At the questioning stage, one student will ask questions of the other.  This role is changed on the next section.  They can predict, clarify and summarize together.

DR-TA (Directed Reading-Thinking Activity) –  This strategy is helpful because of the 4 components that extend and support students’ reading and thinking:  activate prior knowledge, predict, read, revisit prediction to confirm or revise.  First, the teacher asks the class to brainstorm words or ideas associated with a topic.  These are recorded.  Second, students examine the text’s or chapter’s features such as illustrations, graphs, charts. . . .  They form predictions and questions of what they will read.  Third, they have a purpose to read.  Read.  Finally, students discuss the predictions that were confirmed.  They discuss the predictions that they revised as they read, and they look at their lists to see if further reading is still needed before predictions can be confirmed or revised.     

TAG (Textbook Activity Guide) – A TAG is designed to support students as they read.  Prompts are written for the students to help them focus on strategic processes and self-monitoring strategies to help them understand a text.  The teacher reads the section on her own first, highlighting critical content.  A TAG is then created by the teacher to guide the students to this content as they read.  In a TAG, the student works with a partner or small group.  Words like “predict” and “skim” are often used in a TAG, as well as references to the nonfiction text features (glossary, bold-faced words, maps, etc).  Questions are asked and page numbers of where the answers are are given.  This can become a study guide.

Cornell Note-Taking This strategy is effective for helping students understand and remember more of what they read or view.  It supports students in making connections, developing questions, focusing and monitoring their reading, and analyzing what they have learned.  Teacher will model the following first.  Fold a piece of paper in half.  One side is for questions, the other side is for notes, and leave a space at the bottom for summarizing.    During reading or while viewing a video clip, take notes, and develop questions that your notes would answer.  Use these notes to summarize the main ideas at the bottom of the page.  Have students do this individually, then compare with a partner.

Graphic Organizers – Depending on the text structure, prepare an appropriate graphic organizer for students to fill out as they read. 

AFTER READING

Exit Slips – This strategy is good for assessing what a student has learned at the end of class.  Exit slips are short prompts given to students for a focused writing that will give the teacher feedback about the learning.  Some exit slip prompts may include:  Write about something you learned today.  What questions do you still have?  How did what we learned today connect with what we learned prior?   

GIST (Generating Interactions Between Schemata and Texts) – This strategy helps students to write organized summaries.  Teacher models this first by finding a short paragraph that details a concept, event, time period, description, problem, or sequential directions.  Read the 1st sentence, and have class summarize that sentence in 15 words or less.  Read the 2nd sentence.  Now have the class combine the first and second sentence into one sentence summarized in 15 words or less.  Continue doing this until the paragraph is read, and the whole paragraph is summarized into one sentence of 15 words or less.  Have students practice on their own paragraph.

Conceptual Questions After the Passage – Have students answer questions after reading to help with recall and to apply conceptual information to new situations.

Good Readers of Informational Text

Good readers of nonfiction are ACTIVE readers!  Your students should read with a pencil in hand to be engaged at all times

  • Have clear goals for their reading
  • Preview the text before reading, noticing the nonfiction text features
  • Activate prior knowledge
  • Make predictions
  • Use meaning, and expect the text to make sense
  • Monitor their reading ~ ask “Do I understand this?”
  • Make connections:  text to self, text to text, text to world
  • Create visual images
  • Use the text features (heading, captions, maps, etc.) actively and consciously
  • Draw inferences and conclusions
  • Ask questions as they read
  • Read different kinds of informational texts differently
  • Skim and scan to recheck information
  • Locate information
  • Adjust reading rate to match text demands
  • Make a plan when reading ~ take notes in margins, use a color coded post-it-note system of interesting information, confusing parts, questions. . . 
  • Identify important ideas and words
  • Shift strategies to match purpose
  • Retell, summarize, synthesize
  • Use fix-up strategies:  read on and go back, backtrack, context clues, make substitutions, break unfamiliar words into parts

Nonfiction Prompts

  • I learned. . .
  • I never knew. . .
  • I already knew that. . .
  • I was wrong to think. . .
  • I wonder why. . .
  • I still don’t know. . .
  • An important date is. . .
  • The confusing thing is. . .
  • This helped me explain. . .
  • I was suprised. . .
  • I also want to read. . .
  • The index helped me. . .
  • I like learning. . .
  • I would recommend this book to. . .
  • I would like to share my learning by. . .
  • Some interesting facts are. . .
  • I want to learn more about. . .
  • This book answered my questions about. . . 

Some ideas from this page were taken from: 

http://usd262.com/modules/groups/homepagefiles/cms/3550/File/Curriculum/Literacy/Comprehension/Textstructure_resources.pdf

Allen, Janet.  Tools For Teaching.  Stenhouse Publishers, 2004.

Hoyt, Linda.  Make It Real.  Portsmouth, NH:  Heinemann, 2002.

www.essdack.org ~ Reading and Writing Consultant, Kristi Orcutt

Comments are closed.